Reading Reflections Post 5
![]() |
| Note: Istock by Getty Images, n.d. |
One of the things I thought of this while reading, this week was
the phrase coined by educator Emily Style (1984) of “windows and mirrors” where
she discussed the framework and importance of building an inclusive curriculum.
One group of this week's articles discussed the value of children experiencing
intercultural encounters and having a shared understanding, where the concern
is placed on more participative encounters that allow children to experience an
increased awareness of themselves and others.
I thought it interesting that in their article, Piipponen and Karlsson
(2019) identified the importance of the
quality of the interaction between the participants of the intercultural
encounter versus the focus of comparing and contrasting one culture to another
that tends to take place in many exchange type programs.
The Storycrafting method the authors speak of allows the intercultural participants to share different types of stories, personal experiences, stories intended to entertain, stories intended to challenge, or stories from shared experiences, where children primarily guide the experience, instead of the teachers. They also note that the role a teacher takes in the Storycrafting event can impact the way in which the children will view the experience, when teacher lead, it was looked at as an academic experience in which they graded or critiqued their international partner. When the teacher encouraged a more participatory culture, the children started to create a shared narrative with their counterparts, creating a more meaningful exchange between the two cultures.
A book I read last week, speaks simply to intercultural interaction. Even speaking different languages, the ease and joy children can find if no one is telling them to judge.
Words to Make a Friend: A Story in Japanese and English
by Donna Jo Napoli
A quote spoke to the author of one of the articles of the week. It spoke to me as a person, but also as a soon-to-be librarian that may well be responsible for the selection of stories my patrons have access to, the recommendations I give to them, but also maybe for how I tell the stories of the projects I'll work with in the future.
“For each of us, life is a story. There are characters, conflicts, plot developments, crises, interludes, twists, and resolutions. Sometimes the story make sense; sometimes it doesn’t. But there’s still value in the story itself, even when you can’t add up the parts and understand the whole. A good story can lead you toward insight—perhaps wisdom—regardless of whether or not you fully understand it. Maybe that’s why storytelling has always been so important to me” (Myers, 2008, 282).
I believe it also speaks to those people whose stories we are willing
to select, read, or promote, versus the ones we leave because they will cause
conflict or we don’t understand them or don’t have the same viewpoint. Those
stories don’t have less value and somebody, some child, some student, somewhere;
NEEDS that story. It resonates with their life, their experiences, their
culture.
Grisby (2014) works hard to put programs in place that foster
independence in students. She believes that interest drives learning and that it
is more important to teach students independence in their book selections and
book interests than it is to label books with color-coded stickers that
indicate text difficulty and the appropriateness for certain readers or the AR or
Lexile levels. I think our goal is to teach children to be curious, look for
themselves, and ultimately, to be independent thinkers. I think her programs work
to support that goal.
![]() |
| Note: Novikov, Sergey, n.d. |
Program planning (a part of which must be marketing) is integral to
program success and possibly, program and library continuation. If potential
patrons don’t know of your existence and are unaware of upcoming programs, then
there is little to no participation. With no participation, it is hard validating
the continuation of your presence, that money is needed for programming, of proving
that you make a difference.
It surprised me to realize that a facility as established as Johns
Hopkins, could possibly have a problem with advertising, promotion, or
marketing. But Haver (2014), indicated that one of the primary problems their
new family resource center had was that no one knew it was there, and no one
knew about the programs it offered. The director did the research and worked
with the hospital staff to identify safety concerns and the ideal timeframe to
schedule the programs. The family resource staff also ensured there were
accommodations for those children who may not be able to participate as the
program was originally designed. For instance, there was an art program scheduled
for painting a mural, and even though the intent had been to perform the
activity with brushes, fingers and toes were acceptable alternatives. This also
reminds me of previous discussions a few weeks back about the importance of being
aware of your audience, of their potential limitations, and being able to
adjust your program accordingly.
They also learned how to better promote and advertise their
programs and worked with the calendar year to tie in different celebrations or
monthly spotlights. They promoted their programs with flyers, announcements,
and displays in locations sure to draw attention and get the word out. I
thought their display was amazing and have attached an image from the article
below. I think everyone working towards the program’s success, helps get access
to those who want and need it.
![]() |
| Note: ACH FRC Library November 2013 display window. |
I was hospitalized briefly at one of our military facilities and I
was so grateful to the roving library, which at the end of the day was a lot of
books on a cart. It worked. They came by our rooms to see if we wanted anything
to read from the cart and checked the items out to our room. I don’t know if
this program is still active in our facilities, but programs that make patients
feel less alone and isolated, are greatly appreciated.
This Week's Reading List
This week's book selection was as always a joy to research, and I enjoyed finding so many people to choose from for the biography selection, I hope you enjoy the ones I found. And of course, what's a story list without aliens invading our home planet, but all under the guise of a secret identity or reading about our superheroes come to life. Our libraries have a great selection of stories, and I hope we continue to have a variety of writers providing them.
Biography
Biographies give children an opportunity to learn about people who’ve
made a difference in the world at a level they can understand. I think it’s
important to keep as close to the facts as possible with these stories, but
they are, of course, in a story format to help our young readers better understand
the information. I found some great people who have made their mark in history.
All but one of my selections have passed, but there are many more from these and other publishers as well, who are alive and continue to make a difference. Enjoy!
I Dissent: Ruth Bader Ginsburg Makes Her Mark by Debbie Levy
A Computer Called Katherine by Suzanne Slade
Who
Was Marie Curie? by Megan Stine
Fantasy/Sci-Fi
Selecting books from this category was amazing. There is so much to
choose from for kids these days. From aliens to dinosaurs (always a kid
favorite), and of course all things superhero and Disney that have gone from
film to children’s books, these were a pleasure to select and read.
Crash!: The Kid From Planet Z by Nancy Krulik
World of Reading: This is Black Panther by Alexander West
Wall-E:
Rogue Robots by Jillian Joy Samuels
Jurassic World: Danger Dinosaurs! By Courtney Carbone
References
Grigsby, S.K.S. (2014).
The story is more important than the words: A portraits of a reader-focused
library program. Knowledge Quest, 43(1), 22-28. https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/credits/docview/1561140971/se-2.
Haver, M.K. (2014) Books, children,
dogs, artists: Library programs for the entire family. Medical Reference
Services Quarterly, 33(2), 211-217. https://doi.org/10.1080/02763869.2014.897523
Myers, E. (2008). Storyteller.
New York: Clarion Books.
Piipponen, O. &
Karlsson, L. (2019) Children encountering each other through storytelling:
Promoting intercultural learning in schools. The Journal of Educational Research,
112(5), 590-603. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220671.2019.1614514
Image Credits
All images were obtained via Amazon.com unless credited separately.















This was a great blog to read! I have read about windows, mirror, and sliding glass doors in so many of my classes in this program and every time I read articles that can relate back to it, I am so happy! I loved the article by Piipponen and Karlsson that you mentioned and agree that it related so well to Styles' framework. I also love the personal touch you brought to the post with your story about the library cart in the hospital. It really is amazing how much a book can help and the importance of making sure that there are programs, even as small as a cart library, in places like that! Thanks for sharing this week. -Rebecca Welch
ReplyDeleteHey Showanda,
ReplyDeleteI really like your focus for this week. Storytelling is a communal experience that brings us all together and through that community it is so important to promote intercultural storytelling. All stories are important and the opportunity for all listeners and readers to see themselves within the story is important for them and important for us as a world. It deepens our understanding and sense of connection with one another. You are so correct about the importance of what stories we choose to promote as librarians.
I also wanted to comment on how diverse and varied your reading was for this week. In my own blog I mentioned that nonfiction is an area I don't dabble in too much, so I feel sort of lost when I get into it. Your selection was very well rounded and covered a variety of interesting people and topics. Great work!
All the best,
-John Fowler